Ecosystem-based fisheries management approaches aim to—informed by the affected ecosystem—holistically manage existing fish stocks. Such approaches, particularly establishing conservation-sensitive fisheries closures, afford fisheries contributions towards international conservation targets (e.g., global initiative to protect 30% of the ocean by 2030). Designs of fisheries closures should include important areas to fisheries, such as potential spawning grounds. Larval fish data are often only available locally and only for economically important species (e.g., bluefin tunas). Because of this, broad-scale information on potential fish spawning grounds are scarce. Nishikawa et al. (1985) represents the only known repository for near-global (50°N-50°S) historical larval distribution data on multiple pelagic species. We use this digitized data together with environmental data from Earth System Models to build larval habitat suitability models using Boosted Regression Trees for 17 pelagic fish taxa. We provide information on hemispheric seasonality and potential drivers of larval distribution for all taxa considered. Using Principal Component Analysis, we identify seasonal larval hotspots common to multiple species in the Pacific and Indian Oceans. The cross-taxa nature of the identified larval hotspots could imply conservation benefits beyond fisheries.